note: names of this paper have been changed to protect the identity of the people. or to keep from answering awkward questions from random people....
People always ask me what happened. I don’t know. If I had known, I would have stopped it.
I remember painting our nails. I remember it so clearly; sitting by the edge of the pool as the brush glossed maroon polish over my toenails. We used to laugh about our classmates, about people we didn’t know, and about life. The laughter is what I miss the most. The easy laughter. Now it is forced and awkward, as if we both knew the other was only laughing to laugh on the pretense of enjoying the time spent together.
I remember talking about our crushes; she’s the one who gave me the nerve to admit how I felt about John. We nervously giggled by the pool that day, scared and excited about the future. We would tell each other everything. When people asked who my best friend was, there was no hesitation. Samantha Wallson. I know there was jealousy and insecurity, but we worked so well as best friends that we were never afraid to admit our deepest thoughts and fears. When we went to the Cape, the beach was calm and clear. We built sandcastles, I think, or maybe we sunbathed, flipping through trashy magazines. I remember the night we took the golf-cart out and drove around the complex in the damp evening. We thought we heard a ghost. Or maybe she did; she’s so skittish. We listened to her cell-phone messages and suppressed our laughter at what Rob had said. I remember we kept losing service and I kept having to inch the cart up until she got enough service bars. We huddled in the cart, laughing and listening in the warm summer air.
She told me about her first kiss, and we laughed about the awkwardness. One time we sent this stupid plastic egg down her river, and with it our “feelings” for this one crush. How ridiculous! We thought we could let the water take our feelings away and that we could let go of pain so easily. Perhaps then we could, but now it is different.
I used to think Sam was fun. Behind every joke was a happy spirit waiting to bubble out more insane laughter and behind every smile was a full heart. We went through guys, or at least, she did, and how we talked! I think sometimes we thought we were adults, giving each other relationship advice. I told her about breaking up with Sander. I was so scared and confused but I told her and she helped me through it. I think she told me what to say, though I can’t quite recall.
One time in my pool we played this balancing game, trying to stand on this one float together. Of course we never got it; we kept falling over right as we gained balance. We would explode into hysterics of shrieking laugher and barely have enough time to gasp for air before we plunged into the water. When we came up, still laughing, we’d point to each other and smile at how ridiculous we were.
We went to this garden near the end of last year. It was a small nature conservatory and we walked through the woods talking about Robby and Will and how they all talked about her when we weren’t there. I made some joke about them being obsessed with her. That’s the way it was with us; I was always making little sarcastic comments and she would laugh, and then elaborate. We sat down in the sun and chatted about our other friends. We always used to jest insults at each other but each of us knew the other was perfect. We each thought the other was flawless and so we both respected the hell out of each other. I felt a kind of sisterly love towards her. She knew I wouldn’t be the same carefree fun-loving person with out her, and I knew she’d be way too stressed out all the damn time if it weren’t for me.
Anyway it’s all so fucked up now and I can’t even begin to explain why. I’ve tried to explain how close we were, the bond we had, but it just hasn’t worked. Reading this now, I know it doesn’t do justice to the way we were. You don’t understand; we told each other everything. We knew each others dreams. We felt each others pain and joy and we were as one. It sounds odd when I try to explain it, because I just can’t find the words. She was a sister in all practical senses of the word. The only way I can describe it is that I felt completely comfortable around her; silences weren’t awkward and there was no hidden meaning in our words. Our time spent together wasn’t time wasted, it was time cherished and it was so wonderfully comfortable. It is a rare thing to feel that open with a person, to feel so utterly yourself around them. That’s the way I was with her.
We didn’t have one falling out, we had about twenty. Maybe more. It just started to deteriorate and it’s my fault. It’s her fault. It’s both of our faults, and it’s neither of our faults. People change, relationships change. We used to walk on my road together, all the time. This one time we talked about the future, going to college and getting married. We both agreed that when we grew up, no matter where we went to school, we would keep in touch, and when we got married, we’d each be the others bridesmaid. We said our kids would grow up together. How naive we were. We didn’t know how time can murder this kind of kinship, how even the best of us can die a little inside.
The day I knew it would never be the same was the day I had to let it go. I had held onto this tiny shard of hope, this miniscule piece of remembrance- not wanting to let our life slip through my fingers. This whole ordeal has been like watching water cupped in your hands. You can’t see where that damn crack is but the water keeps on seeping out and you stare at your reflection in the draining water, and you are powerless, utterly powerless to cease the trickle. I watched her turn away, again and again. I felt my own jealously kill us and I knew it. I hated it, but I couldn’t stop it. And now it’s a shell of the old love. I say love because that’s what I felt for her. Not a passionate love one might have for a boyfriend or partner, but a love one might hold for a sibling. A kind, enlivening love; a simple, appreciative love. As I said, I felt inexplicably tied to her as if we had been kin. We made each other laugh.
It’s dead now, the life we once had between us. The sorrow I feel towards her, about it all, is almost too much to write about. She has shaped me so indelibly in so many small ways, and now I have nothing to cling to anymore. She doesn’t talk to me anymore, on account of our last talk. Fight, really. And I haven’t tried to speak to her because I know now it won’t make a damn bit of difference. Call me a cynic, but you haven’t been through what I have with her and you don’t know how many times I’ve tried, she’s tried. She can’t change now, back to how she was before, and she shouldn’t have to; Robby loves her and that’s all she needs. That’s not to say she’s a terrible person now; she’s not. Perhaps she is more herself than she has ever been, but all I know is she’s not the girl I grew up with. She’s not the Sam from those long Lost District walks, and she sure as hell isn’t the shy-with-boys girl from middle school. She is something entirely foreign. I don’t want you to think she is bad the way she is, it’s just that she’s not the best friend I once knew. She’s some imposter, who is probably equally likable, but none-the-less, wholly unalike. Almost all traces of the “old” Sam have been swept under the carpet.
Sometimes I lie in bed at night and wonder if I caused all of this. Am I the only one who sees the change? Alex told me I wasn’t, that I was right, because Sam wasn’t ever like that with me before. But Alex also said I was wrong, because towards the end of us being friends, Sam was like that with other people. She was one way with me, and another with outsiders. That’s what ultimately got to me, her mind. I didn’t understand how she couldn’t see what she was doing and I couldn’t stand the secrecy of it all. That insane secrecy that perhaps only I saw. It’s my fault. But it’s hers, too. It really doesn’t matter whose fault it is anyway, because once the bomb goes off, no one is left alive to point the finger at the guy who walked it with it strapped on.
People ask me what happened. I don’t know. If I had known, I don’t think I would have stopped it, knowing where I ended up. Sometimes, heartbreak makes you stronger. Sometimes.